Contact Us
List Your Business
Modify Your Business

Florida Keys Italian Restaurants

Location: Key West | Marathon | Islamorada | Key Largo | Big Pine & The Lower Keys

Key West

  • La Trattoria Venezia - – The atmosphere is European and romantic, and the cuisine is deliciously authentic Italian. The extensive menu covers all the bases, including pastas, chicken, seafood, steak and more. From the insalate to the tiramisu, you’ll be pleased with La Trattoria Venezia.

    524 Duval Street Key West, FL 33040
    Phone: (305) 296-1075

  • Mangia Mangia Pasta Cafe - Open for dinner nightly, Mangia Mangia offers a menu full of Italian dishes, including house specialties such as pollo al quattro formaggio and cappellini schmappellini. Pasta is made fresh daily. You will not leave this pasta café feeling hungry!

    900 Southard St Key West, FL 33040
    Phone: (305) 294-2469

  • Abbondanza Italian Restaurant - Abbondanza serves tasty Italian dishes in a family-friendly environment. A variety of entrees are all served with salad and crusty bread (with olive oil for dipping, as an added plus). The portions are plenty big and the prices are reasonable.

    1208 Simonton St Key West, FL 33040
    Phone: (305) 292-1199

  • Arte - Located on busy Duval Street, Arte offers a change of pace from standard seafood or pub food. Enjoy a variety of Italian dishes here.

    917 Duval St Key West, FL 33040
    Phone: (305) 292-0700

  • Antonia's - Antonia's has been a favorite local Italian eatery for 25 years. Fresh pasta, local seafood, veal and steak entrees and more are complemented by a full bar and extensive wine list. Don't miss the homemade desserts.

    615 Duval St Key West, FL 33040
    Phone: (305) 294-6565

  • Opera Italian Restaurant - You’ll enjoy dining at its finest and a variety of Italian specialties at Opera Italian Restaurant. Wonderful presentation makes the exquisite dishes a feast for the eyes as much as the palate.

    613 Duval St Key West, FL 33040
    Phone: (305) 295-2705

  • Cudjoe Landing Incorporated
    457 Drost Dr Summerland Key, FL 33042
    Phone: (305) 745-9999
back to top


  • Jo-Jo's Restaurant
    US 1 MM 60 Grassy Key, FL 33050
    Phone: (305) 289-0600

  • Little Italy Restaurant - Something for everyone at Little Italy, including kids and calorie counters. Breakfast, lunch and dinner available. You’ll find the traditional Italian dishes at reasonable prices and sinful desserts such as hot chocolate pecan pie and tiramisu.

    US 1 MM 68.5 Long Key Marathon, FL 33045
    Phone: (305) 664-4472

  • Marathon Pizza & Pasta - The name says it all. When you’re in the mood for a pizza or plate of pasta, steer your car toward Marathon Pizza & Pasta.

    US 1 MM 50 5429 Overseas Highway Marathon, FL 33050
    Phone: (305) 743-9993

  • Porto Cayo - Porto Cayo offers Italian/Caribbean cuisine in a casual dining environment.
    US 1 MM 61 Hawk's Cay Resort Duck Key, FL 33040
    Phone: (305) 743-7000

  • Upper Crust Pizza - You’ll have trouble deciding what to get at the Upper Crust, where the menu is lengthy and everything sounds good. Pizzas, sandwiches, subs, salads, pastas and more are available, as are tasty desserts and a limited selection of beer and wine.

    US 1 MM 49 2217 Overseas Highway Marathon, FL 33050
    Phone: (305) 743-710
back to top


  • Dino's Ristorante Italiano - Dino’s has two separate areas -- a family dining room where kids can order pizza, and a fine dining room, where couples are treated to crystal, linen and flowers. Menu selections include seafood, beef, veal and pasta. The family dining room is open for lunch and both dining rooms are open for dinner.

    81031 Overseas Hwy Islamorada, FL 33036
    Phone: (305) 664-0727

  • Woody's Italian Gardens - Woody's is a casual eatery where the menu features pizza, subs, pasta and other goodies.

    MM 82 B/S Islamorada, FL 33036
    Phone: (305) 664-4335

back to top

Key Largo

  • Cafe Largo - Café Largo overlooks the Florida Bay and offers diners a variety of fresh seafood entrees in addition to Italian favorites. Watch for local seafood specials.

    MM 99.5 Key Largo, FL 33037
    Phone: (305) 451-4885

  • Old Tavernier Restaurant - Enjoy a traditional Italian dish while dining under the stars in Old Tavernier’s outdoor dining area.

    MM 90.5 Overseas Tavernier , FL 33037
    Phone: (305) 852-6012

  • Anthony's Italian Restaurant - In addition to Italian dishes, Anthony’s offers tasty seafood and steak entrees. Try their calzone and then enjoy a drink in the lounge.

    97630 Overseas Hwy Key Largo, FL 33037
    Phone: (305) 853-1177

back to top

Big Pine & The Lower Keys

  • Pizza Works - Tucked away in a shopping center, Pizza Works offers Italian favorites, and of course, a variety of pizzas.

    Winn Dixie Shopping Center Big Pine, FL 33043
    Phone: (305) 872-1119

  • 2 For $20 Pizza - Enjoy pizza without draining your wallet at 2 for $20 Pizza.
    Mile Marker 31.5 Big Pine Key, FL 33043
    Phone: (305) 872-7444

Dining & Nightlife